WhatsApp against Telegram, honestly
This comparison is usually argued as though one app is private and the other is not, which misses what each is actually built for. WhatsApp is end-to-end encrypted by default and stores a great deal of metadata. Telegram is a more capable messaging platform whose ordinary chats its servers can read. Both facts are true and they matter in different situations.
The differences that matter
| Telegram | ||
|---|---|---|
| End-to-end by default | Yes, messages and calls | No, only Secret Chats |
| Multi-device history | Limited | Full, because the server holds it |
| Group size | Large | Very large, up to 200,000 |
| Metadata retained | Substantial | Substantial |
| Client source available | No | Yes, clients only |
| Works on very old phones | Reasonably | Notably well |
| File sharing limit | Modest | Very generous |
The two, and the third option
End-to-end by default and installed by nearly everyone, which is itself a privacy feature since the alternative is often unencrypted SMS. Check whether your cloud backup is encrypted, because by default it is not.
The better messaging product: faster, better clients, enormous groups, generous file limits and excellent behaviour on weak connections. Treat ordinary chats as visible to the service.
Signal, the third option that resolves the argument: end-to-end by default like WhatsApp, minimal metadata unlike either, at the cost of a smaller network.
SimpleX. No user identifiers at all, not even a random one. The strictest option on this page.
Element. Matrix chat with end to end encryption and servers anyone can run.
Wire. End to end encrypted by default, with a strong business offering.
Viber. Encrypted by default, and the dominant messenger in several countries.
LINE. Dominant in Japan, Taiwan and Thailand, with its Letter Sealing encryption on by default.
Messenger. Now end to end encrypted for personal chats, from the same company as WhatsApp.
Discord. Not private messaging, but where many group chats have moved. No end to end encryption.
Which to use when
- Talking to people who already use it
- Personal conversations you want encrypted with no setup
- Voice and video calls
- Small groups of family and friends
- Large communities and channels
- Sharing large files
- Reading the same chats across several devices
- Poor connections and older phones
- Public discussion rather than private conversation
The honest summary: use Telegram for anything public or communal, use WhatsApp for private conversation with people who have it, and use Signal for the conversations that genuinely need protecting.
The setting both get wrong by default
- Check whether your backup is encrypted WhatsApp offers an end-to-end encrypted backup that is off unless you turn it on and set a password.
- Remember the other person's backup counts A conversation is only as protected as the least careful participant's settings.
- Turn off automatic media saving Received images copied to the gallery get swept into photo backup as well.
- Use disappearing messages where it matters The only reliable limit on how long a conversation exists anywhere.
Telegram for communities and files, WhatsApp for private conversation with people who have it, Signal for what genuinely matters.
Frequently asked questions
Is Telegram less secure than WhatsApp?
For default one-to-one chats, yes, because WhatsApp is end-to-end by default and Telegram is not. For everything else the comparison is more even.
Can I use both?
Yes, and most people effectively do, because the two networks overlap only partly.
Which uses less data?
Telegram, generally, and it is noticeably better behaved on a weak connection.
Read next
A dot in the wrong city is not a broken receiver. It is a WiFi network that moved house.
There is no print button. There is a print service, and an entry in the share menu.
Aeroplane mode and a turn-based game will outlast any setting inside the game itself.
Read next
A search engine gives you a definition. A dictionary tells you how the word behaves.
A contraction timer is a stopwatch with good manners. It is not monitoring anything.
Every one of these apps is a location service with a chat attached. It is worth knowing what it is broadcasting.
